Home

Starless ‘Failed Galaxy’ Is First of Its Kind Ever Seen

4 Comments

Click the link below the picture

.

A potential new type of celestial object has all the makings of a normal small galaxy. It’s rich with the same hydrogen gas that births suns and planets, and it lies within a halo of dark matter, the same invisible stuff that holds galaxies together. Yet it’s missing one key component of glittering galaxies like our own Milky Way: stars.

Nicknamed Cloud-9, the gas cloud is technically the best-yet example of a RELHIC, or Reionization-Limited H I Cloud. The “H I” stands for Cloud-9’s bounty of neutral hydrogen, and “RELHIC” refers to what astronomers believe the object to be: a primordial fossil—or relic—from the universe’s early epochs that, for some reason, never managed to form stars or become a full-fledged galaxy. That makes Cloud-9 a “failed galaxy,” said Rachael Beaton, an astronomer at the Space Telescope Science Institute, during a January 5 press conference at the American Astronomical Society’s 247th meeting in Phoenix, Ariz.

Based on their understanding of dark matter’s behavior and the hierarchical process of galaxy formation, astronomers have long predicted that such starless objects should exist throughout the cosmos. But until recently, RELHICs had been notoriously difficult to spot.

The results—presented by Beaton at the meeting and published in the Astrophysical Journal Letters last November—bolster the case that we’ve finally found one of these elusive phantom galaxies. Cloud-9 first burst onto the astronomy scene in 2023, when the Five-Hundred-Meter Aperture Spherical Radio Telescope in China’s province of Guizhou discovered a nearly 5,000-light-year-wide spherical cloud of hydrogen gas about 14 million light-years from Earth that appeared to be a faint dwarf galaxy, albeit bereft of visible stars. More in-depth studies on the cloud showed that it contains about a million solar masses of hydrogen and some five billion solar masses of dark matter, but researchers couldn’t confirm it to be truly starless. Perhaps, instead, it was indeed a strange sort of dwarf galaxy that was sparsely populated with very old and dim stars.

So Beaton and her colleagues peered once again at the object through the keen gaze of the Hubble Space Telescope. And in all of Hubble’s observations, she said, it found hints of just one star within Cloud-9. It could be that other stars simply went by undetected, but based on further simulations, the team found that the cloud probably couldn’t host more than some 3,000 solar masses worth of stars—a meager smattering that would preclude the object being a dwarf galaxy. This new result not only makes Cloud-9 the foremost REHLIC candidate in astronomers’ catalogs but also a milestone for verifying the common prediction that “not every dark matter halo will have a galaxy in it,” Beaton said.

While the fresh information from Hubble “certainly eliminates the possibility that [Cloud-9] is a dwarf galaxy,” there’s still much left to learn about this peculiar object, says Kristine Spekkens, an astronomer at Queen’s University in Ontario, who was not involved with the work. For instance, she says, Cloud-9 doesn’t have quite as smooth a shape as astronomers would expect. Better mapping of its gas distribution could provide more insights into how exactly it formed and evolved over cosmic time.

Still, it will be difficult to definitively confirm that Cloud-9 is in fact a RELHIC so long as it remains in a league completely of its own, says Ethan Nadler, an astronomer at the University of California, San Diego, who didn’t take part in the Hubble observations. While dubbing the cloud officially “starless” will be challenging, finding similar objects may help researchers shed some light on this dark area of astronomy.

.

https://static.scientificamerican.com/dam/m/3ebcf7647c254bcc/original/STScI-01K7Q4G9NW9TW4F0S95ST16E5M.jpg?m=1767729573.997&w=900

The “failed galaxy” Cloud-9, a dark matter-dominated blob of hydrogen gas some 14 million light-years from Earth. The diffuse magenta represents radio data from the ground-based Very Large Array (VLA) that shows the presence of the gas. The dashed circle marks the peak of radio emission, which is where researchers focused their search for stars. Follow-up observations by the Hubble Space Telescope found no stars within the cloud. The few objects that appear within its boundaries are background galaxies. NASA, ESA, VLA, Gagandeep Anand (STScI), Alejandro Benitez-Llambay (University of Milano-Bicocca) (science); Joseph DePasquale (STScI) (image processing)

.

.

Click the link below for the complete article:

https://www.scientificamerican.com/article/starless-cloud-9-is-an-entirely-new-astrophysical-object/

.

__________________________________________

4 Comments (+add yours?)

  1. vermavkv's avatar vermavkv
    Jan 08, 2026 @ 01:35:57

    A fascinating and beautifully presented piece—this captures the quiet wonder of discovery without overselling it. The idea of a “failed galaxy” like Cloud-9 is both humbling and poetic, and you’ve conveyed the science with clarity while preserving its mystery. It’s a powerful reminder that the universe still holds relics of unrealized possibilities, waiting patiently for us to notice.

    Like

    Reply

    • Mohenjo's avatar Mohenjo
      Jan 08, 2026 @ 05:09:58

      Thank you sir for your comment. However, this article is is work of
      Jenna Ahart a science journalist specializing in the physical sciences.

      Liked by 1 person

      Reply

      • vermavkv's avatar vermavkv
        Jan 08, 2026 @ 05:18:49

        Thank you for the clarification, and I appreciate you pointing that out. My apologies for the oversight. Full credit absolutely belongs to Jenna Ahart, whose work and expertise in the physical sciences truly shine through in the article.

        Like

      • Mohenjo's avatar Mohenjo
        Jan 08, 2026 @ 05:47:47

        👍

        Liked by 1 person

Leave a reply to Mohenjo Cancel reply

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.

TradingClubsMan

Algotrader at TRADINGCLUBS.COM

Comedy FESTIVAL

Film and Writing Festival for Comedy. Showcasing best of comedy short films at the FEEDBACK Film Festival. Plus, showcasing best of comedy novels, short stories, poems, screenplays (TV, short, feature) at the festival performed by professional actors.

Bonnywood Manor

Peace. Tranquility. Insanity.

Warum ich Rad fahre

Take a ride on the wild side

Madame-Radio

Découvre des musiques prometteuses dans la sphère musicale française (principalement, mais pas que...).

Ir de Compras Online

No tiene que Ser una Pesadilla.

Kana's Chronicles

Life in Kana-text (er... CONtext)

Cross-Border Currents

Tracking money, power, and meaning across borders.

Jam Writes

Where feelings meet metaphors and make questionable choices.

emotionalpeace

Finding hope and peace through writing, art, photography, and faith in Jesus.

Wearing Two Gowns.COM

MOVING FORWARD...That's how WINNING is done!”-Rocky Balboa

...

love each other like you're the lyric to their music

Luca nel laboratorio di Dexter

Comprendere il mondo per cambiarlo.

Tales from a Mid-Lifer

Mid-Life Ponderings

Hunza

Travel,Tourism, precious story "Now in hundreds of languages for you."

freedomdailywriting

I speak the honest truth. I share my honest opinions. I share my thoughts. A platform to grow and get surprised.

The Green Stars Project

User-generated ratings for ethical consumerism

Cherryl's Blog

Travel and Lifestyle Blog

Sogni e poesie di una donna qualunque

Questo è un piccolo angolo di poesie, canzoni, immagini, video che raccontano le nostre emozioni

My Awesome Blog

“Log your journey to success.” “Where goals turn into progress.”

pierobarbato.com

scrivo per dare forma ai silenzi e anima alle storie che il mondo dimentica.

Thinkbigwithbukonla

“Dream deeper. Believe bolder. Live transformed.”

Vichar Darshanam

Vichar, Motivation, Kadwi Baat ( विचार दर्शनम्)

Komfort bad heizung

Traum zur Realität

Chic Bites and Flights

Savor. Style. See the world.

ومضات في تطوير الذات

معا نحو النجاح

Broker True Ratings

Best Forex Broker Ratings & Reviews

Blog by ThE NoThInG DrOnEs

art, writing and music by James McFarlane and other musicians

fauxcroft

living life in conscious reality

Srikanth’s poetry

Freelance poetry writing

JupiterPlanet

Peace 🕊️ | Spiritual 🌠 | 📚 Non-fiction | Motivation🔥 | Self-Love💕

Sehnsuchtsbummler

Reiseberichte & Naturfotografie

Spotlight Choices

astrology - life coaching - optimistic reality

INFINITE ENERGY

"قوتك تبدأ من هنا"

Mesime ÜNALMIŞ

Her çocuk hikayelerle büyümeli

Treasurable Life: The Dirty, Divine Truth of Becoming

No shame. No filters. Just everything we were told to hide.

Dr. Edward McInnis

Doctor of Medicine

Ishaya Zephaniah

Explore the dynamic relationship between faith and science, where curiosity meets belief. Join us in fostering dialogue, inspiring discovery, and celebrating the profound connections that enrich our understanding of existence.

Through Pain Suffering , Mental Health , Addictions , Cancer , Death , Drs

Living with Purpose: Finding Meaning Amidst Life's Challenges